Posts Tagged ‘Criticism

Image: Sarah G...

I guess I never thought much about the reliability of online reviews. Sure, when I’m shopping around for computer hardware, I try to read between the lines (of reviews for, say, video cards) to make sure the reviewer knows what he or she is talking about. Their level of computer expertise. What kind of computer they were using in the first place. Those details are important but often left out.

So there’s certainly room for user error. And when it comes to books, movies, or music — well, those things are better left for each individual consumer to decide. Different tastes and all that.

The point is, you should always make your own decisions. Read the rest of this entry »

October 25, 2008 | In: Blogging

Blog Tip #9,472

I don’t pretend to know everything about blogging. Heck, I hardly even have the attention-span to keep at it. But during my short five-month (and counting) journey as a blogger, I’ve noticed that one thing always rings true: the more someone disagrees with you, the more likely you’ll receive gobs of traffic (that’s right — I said gobs). Read the rest of this entry »

June 27, 2008 | In: General

Writing in spite of it all

“How poor are they that have not patience!
What wound did ever heal but by degrees?
Thou know’st we work by wit, and not by witchcraft;
And wit depends on dilatory time.”

- Shakespeare (from Othello)

What makes a person successful? What leads to victory no matter the conflict?

Patience. Perseverance. The willingness to continue on even when everything is going awry.

It’s hard to push forward when you feel that everything you’re working for is meaningless, that you’re not receiving credit or acknowledgment, or gratification seems far off. Negative criticism may be holding you back — you do your best at something only to have it ridiculed and dismissed.

These feelings are difficult to avoid.

But the key to true success is to never give up. Never give your critics an inch, never worry about the future. Continue in spite of all that.

I constantly face this conflict, myself. While I’d like to think I take criticism in stride (and I always try to learn from my mistakes), I find that I will still tend to second-guess myself when confronted with opposition. Old habits die hard, I guess, but I keep going, anyway.

When it comes to acknowledgment, I’m a bit less worried. I write for whoever will listen, and to give myself a voice. In a professional sense, and in college, I write because that is my assignment and it provides income. But in the end, whenever I find my patience diminishing or my morale fading, I always remember why I started writing in the first place, all those years ago.

Because I like to. And no one — nothing — can take that away from me.

Do you ever find your morale slipping?

What do you do in those situations?

A couple weeks ago we talked about how to critique like you mean it. This week, I’d like to take a quick look at dealing with criticism.

Criticism comes in two forms, constructive and destructive, and it’s not very difficult to tell them apart: constructive criticism will be helpful, honest, and ultimately positive, while destructive criticism will belittle and attempt to humiliate.

Regardless of its form, you should always consider the following when dealing with criticism:

  • You (and your writing) are not perfect. There will always be things you could have done better — not that anyone needs to tell you that.
  • People have different tastes. Criticism is subjective.
  • You don’t always need to listen. No one is always right.

Having work criticized can be difficult for anyone, but it’s truly an exercise in perception: criticism can only negatively affect you if you allow it to. It’s not a monster — it can’t physically harm you, it can’t gnaw your limbs off, put them in freezer bags and save them for tomorrow’s dinner. It’s only as bad as you make it. Read the rest of this entry »

If you’ve read any of my previous articles, you know that I’m not a big fan of online critique groups. But why, you ask? I’ll tell you why.

It’s all about the quality.

When you join a critique group, you’re doing it for one reason: to improve your writing. If the feedback you’re getting is not pushing you toward this goal, it simply is not worth it. Read the rest of this entry »